Ex Parte Chamandy et al - Page 7




                          as to obtain the benefit of preventing the detectable marker                            
                          from falling out of the pocket.  Closing all four edges of                              
                          Frowein 087's label except for the opening through which the                            
                          detectable marker is inserted is consistent with Frowein 087's                          
                          illustration of closed long edges and Frowein 087's teaching to                         
                          secure the function strip 11 at both short edges 16 where the                           
                          function strip is folded in toward the product.  Humble et al                           
                          provides one of ordinary skill in the art with a reasonable                             
                          expectation of success since Humble et al teaches inserting a                           
                          detectable marker through an opening in the form of a slot (slit)                       
                          in a wall of a pocket which is closed except for the slot (slit)                        
                          [answer, pp. 10-11].                                                                    

                    Frowein ‘514 is directed to a woven label having an alarm trigger 50 inserted into a          
             completely closed pocket therein during the weaving process of the label and provides no             
             teaching or suggestion to provide a slot in a fabric label wall through which an alarm               
             triggering device is inserted into a pocket in the label.  Humble is directed to an enclosure        
             of tough tear resistant plastic for securing to a flat surface of an article, such as a              
             cardboard record jacket, by pressure sensitive adhesive, the enclosure provided with a               
             slot 45 for accepting a security tag 12 therethrough for retention within the enclosure and          
             a tab 23 for elevating the tag to the ceiling 22 of the enclosure.  When a retailer desires to       
             affix a tag 12 to an article such as a record jacket, the tag may be inserted through the slot       
             45 into an enclosure 10 whereupon the release paper 18 is peeled from the panel 24 of the            
             enclosure exposing the pressure sensitive adhesive 15.  In order to remove the tag 12                
             from the enclosure, upon retail purchase of the record, a razor edge implement 26 is                 
             applied to the enclosure 10 to sever the enclosure at the intersection 21 between walls 19           
             and 20.  The implement 26 includes a platform portion 37 supporting a blade 32.  The                 
             platform portion 37 penetrates the enclosure so as to slip under the end of tag 12, which is         
             located within the enclosure with its end 25 elevated toward the ceiling 22 of the                   






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007