Ex Parte Wang - Page 2



                         1.  A method of interacting with a user on a computer system,                      
                   the method comprising:                                                                   
                         interacting with the user to identify an entity that the user does                 
                   not want;                                                                                
                         setting an anti-entity value based on the identified entity without                
                   setting values for entities that were not presented to the user while                    
                   interacting with the user;                                                               
                         using the anti-entity value to clarify ambiguous input from the                    
                   user by reducing a likelihood that the entity represented by the anti-                   
                   entity value will be considered as having been referenced in the                         
                   ambiguous input.                                                                         

                         15.  A computer-readable medium having computer-executable                         
                   instructions for performing steps comprising:                                            
                         receiving an indication that a user wants to exclude an item from                  
                   consideration without receiving an indication that a user has selected                   
                   an item;                                                                                 
                         setting a value to reduce the likelihood that ambiguous input is                   
                   interpreted as including a reference to the item;                                        
                         providing a response to the user;                                                  
                         after providing the response, receiving ambiguous input that can                   
                   be interpreted as having a reference to the item; and                                    
                         accessing the value to determine how to interpret the ambiguous                    
                   input.                                                                                   

            The examiner relies on the following references:                                                
            Zhilyaev     6,137,911   Oct.   24, 2000                                                        
            Horiguchi et al.  (Horiguchi)  6,282,507   Aug.  28,  2001                                      
            Robinson et al.  (Robinson)  6,801,190   Oct.   05, 2004                                        
                                                  (filed May 26, 2000)                                      

                   The following rejections are on appeal before us:                                        
            1.     Claims 1-25 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 112, first paragraph,                       
                   for failing to comply with the written description requirement                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007