Ex Parte Herz et al - Page 9

            Appeal No. 2006-2556                                                       Page 9              
            Application No. 09/977,155                                                                     

                                                 Summary                                                   
                  Because Willnow does not disclose all of the limitations recited in claims 1-9 and       
            11-14, we reverse the anticipation rejection of those claims.  Because Willnow and Herz        
            do not suggest practicing the invention recited in claims 15-20, we reverse the                
            obviousness rejection of those claims.                                                         


                                               REVERSED                                                    





                               Toni R. Scheiner   )                                                        
                               Administrative Patent Judge )                                               
                                                              )                                            
                                                              )                                            
                                                              ) BOARD OF PATENT                            
                               Demetra J. Mills   )                                                        
                               Administrative Patent Judge )   APPEALS AND                                 
                                                              )                                            
                                                              ) INTERFERENCES                              
                                                              )                                            
                               Eric Grimes    )                                                            
                               Administrative Patent Judge )                                               


















Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November  3, 2007