Ex Parte Blair et al - Page 8


                Appeal No.  2006-2702                                                   Page 8                
                Application No.  09/881,234                                                                   
                      datasets (i.e. N and M) involving a multiplication of data elements                     
                      nN x nM as, stated in instant claims 1 and 13.                                          
                According to the examiner (id.), Altschul teaches that “the sequence segments                 
                can be of any length . . . or certain short sequences thus having a specified                 
                range . . . .”  The examiner recognizes, however, that like Smith, Altschul does              
                “not describe uncompressing data or looping processes.”                                       
                      The examiner relies on Reed to make up for this deficiency in the                       
                combination of Smith and Altschul.  According to the examiner (Answer, page 8),               
                Reed describes “a system and methods that coordinate the transfer of data,                    
                metadata, and instructions between databases to control and process                           
                communications . . . which represents a separation or stripping of metadata from              
                data.”  In this regard, the examiner finds (id.), Reed teaches that “this transfer of         
                metadata and methods allow for the control by the provider and consumer of the                
                types and contents of information subsequently transferred . . . which represents             
                storing minimal information if so desired.”  In addition, the examiner finds (id.),           
                Reed teaches “compressing database, database query, or other file format using                
                PKZIP . . . that represents packing data into an efficient structure using a                  
                redundancy reduction data compression method.”                                                
                      In addition, the examiner finds (id.), Reed teaches “corresponding data,                
                metadata, and instructions in the provider program can control and automate                   
                decryption and decompression of data . . .”; “communication networks that allow               
                both parties to control, filter, store, index, and process communications from                
                each other . . . which represents creating an index in an uncompressed manner”;               
                and “querying a provider database and loops through each communication object                 






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007