Ex Parte Boehler et al - Page 8




             Appeal No. 2006-2736                                                          Page 8              
             Application No. 10/038,167                                                                        


             computer 32 includes a keyboard (not shown), a monitor 36 with a display screen 36a               
             and a graphical input device 38 such as a single button mouse. . . ."  (Col. 4, ll. 7-10.)        


                   "[D]igitized information . . . may be processed by a display module 92 in                   
             response to input received from graphical input device 38 so that a three-dimensional             
             image of the target volume can be displayed on the screen 36a of the monitor 36 and               
             manipulated. . . ."  (Col. 5, ll. 34-41.)  For example, "FIGS. 8a to 8c show the model and        
             three-dimensional image within the main window display undergoing a rotation about a              
             vertical axis as the graphical input device 38 is moved to drag the cursor across the             
             main display window from mid-right to mid-left."  (Col. 13, ll. 22-26.)  For another              
             example, "FIGS. 9a to 9c show the model and three-dimensional image undergoing a                  
             rotation about an axis, angled at about 30° to the horizontal and sloping up and to the           
             right, as the graphical input device 38 is moved to drag the cursor across the main               
             display window from top-left to bottom-right."  (Id. at ll. 26-31.)                               


                   Because we agree with the examiner's finding that rotating an image about a                 
             vertical axis and rotating an image about a 30° axis constitute different control functions,      
             we also agree with his finding that Fenster teaches changing the display of an image via          
             different control functions respectively associated with different movement                       









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007