Ex Parte Belias et al - Page 2

         Appeal Number: 2006-2894                                                   
         Application Number: 10/375,188                                             

                                   THE INVENTION                                    
              The appellants claim a bag or liner for collecting items              
         such as household waste that can produce unpleasant odors.                 
         Claim 1 is illustrative:                                                   
              1.  A bag or liner adapted to collect items, the bag or               
         liner comprising:                                                          
         a first thermoplastic body panel;                                          
         a second thermoplastic body panel, the first and second                    
         body panels joined along a pair of opposing sides and a bottom             
         bridging the sides so as to form an open mouth, the joined first           
         and second body panels forming an interior space for collecting            
         items; and                                                                 
         at least one structure being a patch, tape or pouch, the                   
         at least one structure comprising a first layer being a barrier            
         layer and including an odor-masking and/or neutralizing agent,             
         the first layer being attached to the bag or liner via attaching           
         means such that the odor-masking and/or neutralizing agent is in           
         communication with the interior space.                                     
                                   THE REFERENCES                                   
         Lin                               4,105,144        Aug.  8, 1978           
         Cappuzzo et al. (Cappuzzo)        4,944,393        Jul. 31, 1990           
                                   THE REJECTION                                    
              Claims 1-9, 14-17, 19-25 and 27-29 stand rejected under               
         35 U.S.C. § 103 as being unpatentable over Lin in view of                  
         Cappuzzo.                                                                  
                                      OPINION                                       
              We affirm the aforementioned rejection.                               
              The appellants state that the claims stand or fall together           
         (brief, page 3).  We therefore limit our discussion to the sole            



                                         2                                          


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007