Ex Parte Ball et al - Page 13



            Appeal No. 2006-2920                                                      Page 13               
            Application No. 10/813,501                                                                      

            across resistor 801 (fig. 5) [or resistor 800, fig. 4] becomes less negative                    

            than Vr.                                                                                        

                   We agree with appellants that the inverting (-) input to comparator                      

            840 shown in fig. 5 (i.e., corresponding to node Vs, fig. 4) can never have a                   

            positive voltage potential (and associated positive current flow) with respect                  

            to ground potential.  We note that transistor 10 is OFF (i.e., with NO current                  

            flowing through it) when field coil 32 is energized by current flowing through                  

            transistor 9 [col. 5, line 66 through col. 5, line 3].  Again, we note that when                

            transistor 9 turns OFF, a negative backflow current flows initially through the                 

            parasitic diode to provide a negative voltage drop across resistor 801 to                       

            trigger the comparator to change state to turn ON (i.e., enable) transistors                    

            10 and 841 that function to shunt the field coil backflow current to ground.                    

            Therefore, we agree with appellants that the negative discharge current will                    

            progressively become less negative as the field coil discharges through                         

            transistors 10 and 841 (fig. 5) until a point is reached when the voltage                       

            potential at Vs approaches ground potential (i.e., at the point of full field coil              

            discharge).  However, we note that just before this point of full discharge is                  

            reached, the comparator is triggered to change state (i.e., when Vs > Vr,                       

            but both Vs and Vr are negative with respect to ground potential), as                           

            discussed supra.                                                                                









Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007