Ex Parte Chiu - Page 12



           Appeal No. 2006-3126                                            Page 12            
           Application No. 10/154,060                                                         

                Appellant argues that neither Flynn nor Rusch discloses estimating            

           power currently available from a power supply [brief, pages 9 and 10].             

                We note that we have found supra that Flynn teaches a power                   

           estimator (i.e., microprocessor 112 that performs the function of estimating       

           power currently available from a power supply) [see discussion of claim 6,         

           supra].                                                                            

                Appellant argues that neither Flynn nor Rusch discloses allocating            

           power to each component of a plurality of components of the device based           

           on the one or more current characteristics of the device [brief, pages 9 and       

           10].  Appellant notes that the examiner has relied upon Rusch as teaching          

           allocating power based on a user preference [brief, page 10].  Appellant           

           argues that Rusch’s user preferences relate to service/function preferences        

           of the wireless device and not to individual components within the wireless        

           device among which power is selectively allocated [brief, page 10].                

                We note that we have found supra that Flynn discloses allocating              

           power based on one or more current characteristics of the device and/or            

           associated device components [see discussion of claim 6, supra].  We note          

           that the examiner’s rejection is based on the combination of the references.       

                With respect to Rusch, we note that appellant has acknowledged in the         

           brief that Rusch discloses switching to a lower-power communication link if        

           the battery of the wireless device becomes low based on user preference            







Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007