Ex Parte Paquet et al - Page 3


              Appeal No. 2006-3248                                                                  Page 3                
              Application No. 10/617,585                                                                                  

                     functional acrylate monomers and one or more functional methacrylate                                 
                     monomers provided with said functional groups, and                                                   
                            wherein said crosslinking component for said crosslinkable groups                             
                     is selected from the group consisting of polyisocyanate, polyamine,                                  
                     ketimine, melamine, epoxy, polyacid and a combination thereof.                                       
                     5.  The coating composition of claim 1 wherein said non-functional                                   
                     acrylate monomer is provided with a non-functional group selected from                               
                     the group consisting of linear C1 to C20 alkyl, branched C3 to C20 alkyl,                            
                     cyclic C3 to C20 alkyl, bicyclic or polycyclic C5 to C20 alkyl, aromatic with 2                      
                     to 3 rings, phenyl and C1 to C20 fluorocarbon.                                                       
                     The coating composition comprises “crosslinkable” and “crosslinking”                                 
              components.  The “crosslinkable component” is a “copolymer” which contains                                  
              “crosslinkable groups” and which is polymerized from non-functional acrylate                                
              monomers and functional methacrylate monomers.                                                              
                     The “crosslinking component” “for said crosslinkable groups” is described                            
              in the specification to have “crosslinking groups” which crosslink with the                                 
              “crosslinkable groups” during the curing step to form “crosslinked structures.”                             
              Specification, page 5, lines 1-7.   In other words, the two components                                      
              (crosslinkable and crosslinking) recited in the claims are chemically linked                                
              together when the curing step is completed.                                                                 
                     The crosslinking component is required by the claim to be “selected from                             
              the group consisting of polyisocyanate, polyamine, ketimine, melamine, epoxy,                               
              polyacid and a combination thereof.”  The specification lists specific pairs of                             
              crosslinking components and crosslinkable groups that are generally linked                                  
              together in the coating compositions.  Id., page 9, line 24-page 10, line 4.                                
                     The copolymer contains “non-functional acrylate monomers” and                                        






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007