Ex Parte Verbil et al - Page 10



           Appeal No. 2006-3280                                                                      
           Application No. 09/874,152                                                                
                       notified of the disconnect by playing an announcement                         
                       such as "Your Notification Hold call has been                                 
                       disconnected. If you wish to re-initiate the call,                            
                       please press one now". The calling party either                               
                       confirms the announcement whereupon the call is re-                           
                       initiated by the intelligent peripheral, or the calling                       
                       party simply disconnects.                                                     
                 With the above discussion in mind, we find that Weisser                             
           teaches a method for re-routing a call to an AIN system when a                            
           subscriber line for which the call was intended is busy.  Weisser                         
           discloses playing a recorded message to a calling party while                             
           waiting on hold to be connected to the subscriber line.  Next, we                         
           find that Knoerle teaches a system for providing a continuous                             
           tone to a caller being re-routed from a service node to a central                         
           office (see abstract).  Additionally, we find that Watts teaches                          
           a system wherein an intelligent peripheral initiates a call to a                          
           calling party when said party’s call was dropped while waiting on                         
           hold to be connected with the called party.                                               
                 It is our view that one of ordinary skill in the art would                          
           have duly recognized that the combined teaching of Weisser,                               
           Knoerle and Watts does not amount to the invention as set forth                           
           in representative claim 1.  Particularly, the ordinarily skilled                          
           artisan would have readily been apprised of the fact that the                             
           teachings of the combined references amount to, at best, a method                         
           that allows a calling party to be connected to a called party                             
           when the latter’s line is available for communication, and in the                         
                                                 10                                                  



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007