Ex Parte Curtis et al - Page 6

                Appeal 2006-2085                                                                              
                Application 09/810,629                                                                        

           1          consumers and coordinates the suppliers' fulfillment of consumers'                      
           2          intentions.  It does this by providing the consumer with information                    
           3          about products and suppliers and offering objective advice, among                       
           4          other things.”  (Gershman, col. 35, ll. 38-45).                                         
           5                                                                                                  
           6          8. Gersham states “[t]he user accesses a Web Browser 1810 and                           
           7          requests product and pricing information from the integrator.”                          
           8          (Gersham, col. 35, ll. 47-49).                                                          
           9                                                                                                  
          10          9. Gersham states “[t]he product and pricing information is then                        
          11          formatted into a Web Page 1860 and returned to the customer's Web                       
          12          Browser.”  (Gersham, col. 35, ll. 58-60).                                               
          13                                                                                                  
          14          10. FIG. 24 is a block diagram of an active knowledge management                        
          15          system in accordance with a preferred embodiment of Gershman.                           
          16          (col. 38, ll. 2-4).                                                                     
          17                                                                                                  
          18          11. Business Data Stores and retrieves data provided by the                             
          19          business.  Calculation Performs complex business                                        
          20          calculations.  (Gershman, col. 43, ll. 32-34).                                          
          21                                                                                                 
          22          12. Brockman’s field of the invention is that of comparative                            
          23          evaluation of  telecommunications data.  (Brockman, p. 1, ¶ [0002]).                    
          24                                                                                                  
          25          13.  Brockman states “[c]onventional telecommunications rating and                      
          26          analysis is performed by the telecommunications services provider, or                   
          27          by a third party vendor using data from the telecommunications                          
          28          services provider's billing data.”  (Brockman, p. 1, ¶ [0009]).                         
          29                                                                                                  
          30          14.  Brockman’s invention involves obtaining telecommunications                         
          31          data of a business entity from its telecommunications vendors and                       
          32          providing access to that business entity for aggregated and uniform                     
          33          telecommunications detail data. After obtaining from multiple vendors                   
          34          both the detailed information of a business entity's                                    
          35          telecommunications usage of network services and/or the                                 
          36          accompanying costs for those services, the present invention                            
          37          aggregates the detailed information into a uniform structure to allow                   
          38          the business entity to manage its telecommunications assets and                         

                                                      6                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013