Ex Parte Wagner et al - Page 2

                Appeal 2006-2735                                                                              
                Application 10/758,552                                                                        

                      We AFFIRM.                                                                              
                                  BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION                                                 
                      Appellants’ invention relates to a catalyst composition for use in water                
                gas shift reactions.  The claimed invention requires a catalyst to include a                  
                primary transition metal, a transition metal promoter, and a support material                 
                comprising cerium oxide.  Claim 1, as presented in the Brief, appears below:                  
                             1.  A catalyst suitable for production of hydrogen, said catalyst                
                      consisting essentially of:                                                              
                             a.  a primary transition metal selected from the group consisting                
                      of Group VIII metal, a Group IB metal, cadmium and combinations                         
                      thereof, said primary transition metal being present at a predetermined                 
                      concentration [Primary TM];                                                             
                             b.  a transition metal promoter present at a predetermined                       
                      concentration [Promoter] selected such that a ratio defined by                          
                      [Primary TM]:[Promoter] is greater than 1:1; and                                        
                             c.  a support material comprising cerium oxide and an additive                   
                      selected from the group consisting of gadolinium, samarium,                             
                      zirconium, lithium, cesium, lanthanum, praseodymium, manganese,                         
                      titanium, tungsten, neodymium, and a combination thereof,                               
                wherein said transition metal and said promoter are combined with said                        
                support material to form said catalyst.                                                       
                      The Examiner relies on the following references in rejecting the                        
                appealed subject matter:                                                                      
                Igarashi     WO 00/54879  Sep. 21, 2000                                                       
                Chintawar     WO 00/66486  Nov.  9, 2000                                                      
                Igarashi (as translated)  EP 1 161 991 A1  Dec. 12, 2001                                      
                Silver     US 6,455,182 B1  Sep. 24, 2002                                                     



                                                      2                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013