Ex Parte Breed et al - Page 4



             Appeal 2006-2983                                                                                     
             Application 10/733,957                                                                               
             the claims are not entitled to the benefit of Breed’s filing date under 35 USC § 120.                
             More particularly, the issue is whether the disclosure of Breed provides adequate                    
             support for the claims under 35 USC § 112, first paragraph.                                          

                                             FINDINGS OF FACT                                                     
                    A preponderance of the evidence establishes the following facts:                              
                    The control module of the claims controls deployment of an occupant                           
             restraint device, such as an airbag, and the control module also receives a signal                   
             indicating a measured pressure in a chamber of a seat bladder.  The claims do not                    
             require that the control module control deployment of the airbag in connection                       
             with, or in response to, the received signal of the measured pressure.  Rather, the                  
             independent claims 60, 62, and 65 require only that a single control module both                     
             control deployment of the occupant restraint device and receive a signal of the                      
             measured pressure.  Claims 64 and 66 further require that the occupant restraint                     
             device is an airbag.  Claims 67 and 68 further require that the control module                       
             control at least one other vehicular system, subsystem, or component, such as a                      
             pressure control device to control pressure in the chamber.                                          
                    Breed describes a vehicle seat with a seat portion.  (Breed, Figure 1).  Breed                
             describes that the seat of the invention includes a control module (150), as shown,                  
             for example, in Figures 1, 5, and 9 (Breed, col. 5, l. 35).                                          
                    Breed describes, referring to Figure 1, that the seat of the invention has a                  
             height sensor comprised of transmitter (120) and a receiver (121) for measuring the                  
             height of the occupant.  (Breed, col. 5, ll. 32-33).  The control module (150)                       

                                                        4                                                         



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013