Ex Parte Rose et al - Page 5

                Appeal 2006-3079                                                                                   
                Application 10/708,033                                                                             
                FF4. The ordinary and customary usage of the term “suit” within the                                
                context of playing cards is “a group of similar things forming a set or series;                    
                specific., any of the four sets of thirteen playing cards each (spades, clubs,                     
                hearts, and diamonds) that together make up a pack” (Webster's New World                           
                Dictionary 1424 (David B. Guralnik ed., 2nd Coll. Ed., Simon & Schuster,                           
                Inc. 1984)).                                                                                       
                FF5. Calhoun discloses a card game utilizing cards including sentence                              
                cards 10, picture cards 14, and thumbs-up and thumbs-down scoring cards                            
                30, 33 (Calhoun, col. 3, ll. 32-41).  In playing the game, each player receives                    
                one sentence card 10, a plurality of picture cards 14, a sentence guide or                         
                display means 17, one thumbs-up card 30, and one thumbs-down card 33.                              
                Each sentence card 10 has a plurality of sentences 12 thereon, with                                
                corresponding value indicia 13 for each sentence.  Each picture card 14 has a                      
                plurality of pictorial elements 16 thereon.  Essentially, players can discard                      
                and receive additional picture cards 14 until one player is ready to attempt to                    
                form a chosen sentence 12 by relating the pictorial elements 16 on the                             
                picture cards 14 to words in the chosen sentence 12 “in an interesting,                            
                creative, and/or entertaining way.”  (Calhoun, col. 5, l. 54 to col. 6, l. 26.)                    
                The player explains to the opposing players how the pictorial elements 16 on                       
                the picture cards 14 relate to the words that make up the chosen sentence 12                       
                on the sentence card 10 (Calhoun, col. 6, ll. 33-37).                                              
                              The explanation must show to the other players                                       
                              interesting, creative, and/or entertaining                                           
                              relationships between the picture elements 16 and                                    
                              the words that make up the chosen sentence 12 on                                     
                              sentence card or sentence means 10.  These                                           
                              relationships can be based on rhymes, definitions,                                   


                                                        5                                                          

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013