Ex Parte Cohen - Page 2

                Appeal 2006-3264                                                                             
                Application 10/685,377                                                                       
                            1.  A modular armored vehicle system comprising an armored                       
                      combat vehicle chassis having a plurality of openings and a plurality                  
                      of composite armor plates for absorbing and dissipating kinetic energy                 
                      from high velocity, armor-piercing projectiles, each of said plates                    
                      being adapted for attachment to said chassis and sized to cover at least               
                      one of said openings wherein each of said plates comprises a single                    
                      layer of bodies which are directly bound and retained in plate form by                 
                      a solidified material wherein a majority of each of said bodies is in                  
                      direct contact with at least four adjacent bodies, wherein the solidified              
                      material and the plate are elastic and wherein said bodies have a                      
                      specific gravity of at least 2.4 and are made of a ceramic material.                   

                                            THE REFERENCES                                                   
                Ferguson                        US 4,131,053             Dec. 26, 1978                       
                Middione                        US 6,082,240                   Jul.    4, 2000               
                Cohen (Cohen ‘781)                  US 6,289,781 B1              Sep. 18, 2001               
                Cohen (Cohen ‘075)                  US 6,575,075 B2              Jun. 10, 2003               
                Slater                                         GB 2 277 141 A               Oct. 19, 1994    

                                            THE REJECTIONS                                                   
                      The claims stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as follows:                            
                claims 1-9 over Cohen ‘781 in view of Middione; claims 10, 13, and 14 over                   
                Cohen ‘781 in view of Middione and Cohen ‘075; and claims 10-12 over                         
                Cohen ‘781 in view of Middione and either Ferguson or Slator.                                

                                                 OPINION                                                     
                      We affirm the aforementioned rejections.                                               
                      The Appellant separately argues only the broadest independent claim,                   
                i.e., claim 1, and its dependent claim 5 (Br. 14-26).  Although additional                   
                references are applied to dependent claims 10-13 and independent claim 14,                   
                the Appellant does not provide a substantive argument as to the separate                     


                                                     2                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013