Ex Parte Scharsack - Page 10

                Appeal 2006-3268                                                                             
                Application 10/479,696                                                                       


                      The pressure P2 approximates the pressure in mixing chamber 4 and                      
                is influenced by the pressure Pg (Hofmann: col. 4, ll. 25-28; col. 5, ll. 12-                
                15).  Accordingly, pressure P2 and Pg are interdependent such that a change                  
                in one of them affects the other.  Therefore, the pressure Pg controls pressure              
                P2, and thus provides a measurement of the pressure P2.                                      
                      From the foregoing, we find the “pressure recording element” in                        
                Hofmann’s device constitutes the gas line 18 which provides pneumatic                        
                feedback of the pressure condition in the mixing chamber 4 (and hence                        
                pressure P2) to maintain the pressure drop (P2-P1) across the metering valve                 
                16 constant.  Thus, pressure P2 is pneumatically sensed, measured and                        
                recorded via interdependent pressure Pg, which is used to control the                        
                pressure control valve 50 such that the pressure drop (P2-P1) across the                     
                metering valve 16 is maintained constant.                                                    
                      Accordingly, Hofmann discloses Appellant’s claim 13 feature “a                         
                pressure recording element recording pressure changes at an output side of a                 
                metering device” and with which a “means for regulating a pressure of the                    
                reducing agent” interacts “so that the pressure changes have an influence on                 
                the pressure regulation.”  Moreover, Hofmann discloses Appellant’s claim                     
                26 feature “recording pressure changes at a side of the metering device                      
                facing the catalytic converter system, the pressure changes having an                        
                influence on the pressure regulation.”                                                       
                      Furthermore, because Hofmann’s gas line 18 acts to sense, measure                      
                and record pressure changes, we find that Hofmann discloses a “pressure                      
                sensor” (i.e., gas line 18) as claimed by Appellant in claim 21.                             


                                                     10                                                      

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013