Ex Parte Grellmann et al - Page 4

              Appeal 2007-0058                                                                      
              Application 10/713,600                                                                
              issue revolves around whether Wood teaches a central diagnostic                       
              location being a repository for ultrasound system repair,                             
              maintenance or quality improvement diagnostic information.                            

                                    FINDINGS OF FACT                                                
              Findings with respect to the rejection of claims 1-6 under 35 U.S.C.                  
              § 102(b).                                                                             
                       1. The reference Wood presents a medical ultrasonic                          
                          diagnostic imaging system which is capable of being                       
                          accessed over data communication networks such as the                     
                          Internet.  The Examiner indicates that the claimed                        
                          diagnostic computers are read on the laptop computers                     
                          of the servicemen disclosed in Column 11, lines 14 to                     
                          28.  (Examiner’s Answer 3). The Examiner further                          
                          indicates that the claimed central diagnostics location is                
                          read on the use of the HDI Server for storage of                          
                          diagnostic results, as disclosed in Column 12, lines 66-                  
                          67 and column 13, lines 1-8.  (Examiner’s Answer 3).                      
                       2. A careful reading of the claims in view of the issues                     
                          raised in the Brief and Answer indicate the key                           
                          limitation of claim 1 to be “…whereby said central                        
                          diagnostic location is a repository for ultrasound system                 
                          repair, maintenance, or quality improvement diagnostic                    
                          information obtained by said diagnostic computers from                    
                          a plurality of ultrasound systems.”                                       



                                             4                                                      

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013