Ex Parte Jerg et al - Page 8

            Appeal No. 2007-0358                                                                              
            Application 10/873,477                                                                            
                         2-5 of DE ‘670 by noting that DE ‘670 “discloses a dish rack 2-6...”                 
                         (Amended Appeal Brief at 11.)                                                        
                   7.    Based on Fig. 1 of DE ‘670, the prior art nozzles 7-10 are spaced apart              
                         at different locations within the dishwasher and are integrated with the             
                         bottom surface 6, which is a part of the prior art dish rack.                        
                   8.    The applicants do not identify what specific claim limitation of claim               
                         1 is missing in DE ‘670.                                                             
                   9.    DE ‘670 does not teach the use of an automated condition sensor to                   
                         control the spraying intensity at a respective region of a spraying                  
                         device as recited in appealed claim 11.                                              
                   10. Cooper describes the use of various sensors including a turbidity                      
                         sensor to assist in the dishwasher cycle selection (“no soil, lite soil,             
                         lite soil plus, normal soil and heavy soil”).  (Column 1, lines 18-21;               
                         column 2, lines 1-4 and 28-42; column 4, lines 11-14.)                               
                   11. Cooper teaches that “[t]he turbidity sensor measures the soil content                  
                         in the water which is an indication of the amount of soil on the                     
                         dishes.”  (Column 3, lines 58-59.)                                                   
                   12. Claims 10 and 11 were added by amendment on June 28, 2005, which                       
                         is after the date on which the subject application was filed.                        



                                                      8                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013