Ex Parte Bosko - Page 4


                 Appeal No.  2007-0379                                                     Page 4                   
                 Application No.  10/045,301                                                                        
                                                                                                                   
                       The cabinet:                                                                                 
                       Appellant’s specification provides the following single disclosure regarding                 
                 the concept of a cabinet:                                                                          
                       manufacturing and maintenance costs are reduced, because the                                 
                       treated water source is built in as part of the host equipment,                              
                       thereby eliminating the need for two cabinets, two sets of electronic                        
                       controls, and other redundant systems.  Similarly, installation costs                        
                       are greatly reduced, as only one piece of equipment needs to be                              
                       installed.                                                                                   
                 Specification, page 6, lines 8-12, emphasis added.                                                 


                       The treated water source 12:                                                                 
                       According to claim 1, the treated water source 12 shares at least part of                    
                 the cabinet such that said treated water source 12 is integral with the water-using                
                 unit 10, 102.  In addition, claim 1 requires that the treated water source 12                      
                 comprise (i) a reverse osmosis water treatment system 201 including (ii) a flexible                
                 reservoir 22 in which water treated by the reverse osmosis water treatment                         
                 system 20 is stored.                                                                               


                       The host system 14, 106:                                                                     
                       According to claim 1 the host system performs host functions 14, 106.                        
                 According to appellant’s specification “[s]uch host functions [14, 106] may                        
                 include, without limitation, ice-making, beverage dispensing, and storage of cool                  

                                                                                                                    
                 1 According to appellant’s specification (page 6, lines 16-17), the “treated water source 12 may   
                 include a water treatment unit 20, such as an R/O [(reverse osmosis)] unit, coupled to a reservoir 
                 22.  The reservoir 22 is preferably a flexible laminate bag.”                                      





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013