Ex Parte Wollenberg et al - Page 9

                Appeal 2007-0510                                                                                 
                Application 10/699,507                                                                           
                                                                                                                 
            1          O’Rear also discloses that a convenient way to measure the stability                      
            2   of lube base oils is using the Oxidator Test.  There are two forms of the test:                  
            3   Oxidator BN and Oxidator A.  O’Rear, para. [0031].                                               
            4          The Oxidator A test is a measure of oxidation stability during                            
            5   shipping and storage.  O’Rear, para. [0031].                                                     
            6          Another method for studying the stability of lube base oils during                        
            7   storage is to monitor floc and sediment formation when stored in an oven                         
            8   while exposed to air.  O’Rear, para. [0034].                                                     
            9          According to the method disclosed in O’Rear, 50 grams of lube base                        
           10   oil is placed in a loosely capped 7 ounce bottle and placed in an oven at                        
           11   150°F.  The sample is inspected periodically for an increase in color or                         
           12   formation of floc or sediments.  The test is run for 90 days.  O’Rear, para.                     
           13   [0034].                                                                                          
           14                4.     Tolvanen                                                                     
           15          The invention disclosed in Tolvanen relates to a method and device                        
           16   for determining the stability or storability of oil.  Tolvanen at 1:6-7.                         
           17          The invention is based on the finding that the stability of oils can be                   
           18   determined promptly and reliably by measuring the intensity of light                             
           19   scattering from the oil surface.  Tolvanen at 2:1-4.                                             
           20          The method may be used to measure the contents of substances                              
           21   insoluble in heavy oil fractions derived from petroleum or in their mixtures.                    
           22   Tolvanen at 3:17-19.                                                                             
           23          Figure 1 illustrates a measuring device 10.  The device comprises a                       
           24   light source 11, a sample vessel 12, and an indicator 14.  Tolvanen at 2:54-                     
           25   56.                                                                                              



                                                       9                                                         

Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013