Ex Parte Satkunanathan et al - Page 4



              Appeal 2007-0519                                                                                           
              Application 10/723,324                                                                                     

              3. Christiano (col. 6, ll. 34-37) describes a system for managing software                                 
              licenses comprising a license server that stores licenses. When a user wants to use                        
              a particular program, a request for a license to operate the program is sent to the                        
              license server. If the user is permitted to operate the program according to a license                     
              policy, the server assigns a license for that program to the client computer system                        
              and the user can then operate the program. The Christiano system takes corrective                          
              action when the license is violated, including denying a license when the maximum                          
              number of licenses for the program have been assigned (col. 7, ll. 9-11).                                  
              4. Christiano’s license server includes a database of license records. These                               
              records may include software package and license descriptions (col. 9, ll. 44-50).                         
              They may also include a key.                                                                               
                     The “KEY” provides an authentication, such as an X-digit number or string                           
                     of characters, which allows the server process to verify that the package                           
                     description has not been tampered with.                                                             
              Col. 11, lines 45-48.                                                                                      
              5. According to Christiano (referring to Figure 9)                                                         
                            [i]f a license record is available in the database, then in optional step                    
                     163, the key stored in the found license record is verified to determine if the                     
                     license record has not been tampered with and is legitimate … . If the record                       
                     is not legitimate, then step 180 is implemented [i.e., step 180 = “Is there                         
                     another record in license database for requested product?”].                                        
              Col. 19, lines 17-25.                                                                                      
              6. We cannot find, and Appellants have not shown where, in the Specification                               
              the claim term “corrupted” is defined.                                                                     
                                                           4                                                             



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013