Ex Parte Rubenstein - Page 15

               Appeal 2007-0631                                                                            
               Application 10/379,652                                                                      
               mounted connector (Answer 8).  Therefore, as discussed above with regard                    
               to claims 1, 6, and 10, Hristake teaches a PWB encompassed by Appellant’s                   
               claim 18.  In response, Appellant asserts that Hristake fails to teach that                 
               when the insertion force has been removed, the engaged position maintains a                 
               force to bias the board into the connector and prevent the board from                       
               becoming disconnected from the connector (Br. 12).  According to                            
               Appellant, Hristake “teaches that after the lock engages the locking pin, the               
               PC board is thereafter held in place by friction force provided by the                      
               connector and by some supplementary mechanisms . . . used along the edges                   
               of the PC board, to prevent dislodgment of the PC board from the rack (id.).                
               We disagree for the reasons set forth with regard to claim 6.  Accordingly,                 
               we affirm the rejection of claim 18 under 35 U.S.C. § 102(b) as being                       
               anticipated by Hristake.                                                                    

               Claim 19:                                                                                   
                      Claim 19 is drawn to a device for aiding in latching an electronic                   
               circuit board in a mated relationship with an electrical connector, wherein                 
               the connector is located at a back end of a housing.  The device comprises:                 
                      1.  a first end for engaging a front surface of the housing;                         
                      2.  means for pivoting the first end around an outer comer of a circuit              
               board to be latched; and                                                                    
                      3.  a second end disposed laterally from the first end.                              
               Claim 19 requires that the second end comprises                                             
                      a.  a latch mechanism for releasably latching to a pin mounted on the                
               board wherein operation of the latch mechanism provides over travel of the                  



                                                    15                                                     

Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013