Ex Parte Willer et al - Page 5


                 Appeal 2007-0869                                                                                      
                 Application 10/648,587                                                                                
                 Product Information Data Sheet for BC21313A both describe single chip                                 
                 Bluetooth devices.  These data sheets identify that the Bluetooth is provided                         
                 input from an external oscillator.  We find no disclosure in these documents,                         
                 nor has the Examiner identified any disclosure, of the same external                                  
                 oscillator being used by other systems.                                                               
                        We find that it is common knowledge that computer systems often                                
                 make use of a master system clock (an oscillator) which provides input to all                         
                 timing circuits.  The system clock in such systems is typically required so                           
                 that events and data transfer within the computer system can be coordinated.                          

                                                        ANALYSIS                                                       
                        Independent claim 1 recites “one and only one reference oscillator in                          
                 the housing providing mixing signals to the GPS receiver and the wireless                             
                 transceiver, the GPS receiver and wireless transceiver not sharing any                                
                 components other than the reference oscillator.”  Independent claim 26                                
                 recites the limitation “wherein the wireless transceiver means and the GPS                            
                 receiver share a common oscillator and only the common oscillator.”  Thus,                            
                 the scope of independent claims 1, and 26 require a GPS unit share an                                 
                 oscillator with a transceiver and that the oscillator is the only element shared                      
                 by the GPS unit and transceiver.  The Examiner relies upon Peterzell for this                         
                 teaching.  As discussed above we find that Peterzell teaches a device which                           
                 contains a GPS unit and a transceiver that have separate signal paths.                                
                 However, we find no teaching or suggestion in  Peterzell that the two units                           
                 should both receive input from the same reference oscillator.  Similarly we                           
                 find no teaching or suggestion in McCarthy of sharing an oscillator as                                


                                                          5                                                            

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013