Ex Parte Overton et al - Page 4

              Appeal 2007-1008                                                                        
              Application 10/208,861                                                                  

                                                  ISSUE                                               
                    The issue in this case is whether the Examiner erred in finding that the          
              prior art discloses partially curing a first layer of coating on a  fiber at a first    
              coating/curing stage and further curing the first layer of coating on the fiber         
              at a second coating/curing stage.                                                       
                                        FINDINGS OF FACT                                              
                    Appellants claim an apparatus for curing a coated fiber including a               
              first coating curing stage which partially cures a first layer of the coating of        
              the fiber and a second coating curing stage located downstream from the                 
              first coating curing stage to further cure the first layer of the coating.  The         
              time between the first coating curing stage and the entrance to the second              
              coating curing stage is at least 40 msec.  Appellant discloses that optimal             
              curing of the first layer of coating is achieved by the recited time delay              
              between the first and second coating curing stage of the first layer of coating         
              (Specification p. 13).  A second layer of coating is applied by a coater                
              downstream of the second coating curing stage of the first layer of coating.            
                    Mensah discloses an apparatus for curing a coated fiber in which a                
              fiber is coated by a coater 18 and proceeds to a coating curing stage 20                
              downstream of coater 18 (Figure 1).  The cured fiber receives a second                  
              coating by secondary coater 22 and then proceeds to a second coating curing             
              stage 23.  Mensah does not disclose partial curing of a first layer of coating          
              or a second curing the first layer.  Rather, the first layer of coating in              
              Mensah is cured only once and completely at a first coating curing stage 20.            




                                                  4                                                   

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013