Ex Parte McBrearty et al - Page 7

                Appeal 2007-1340                                                                               
                Application 09/996,125                                                                         
                Because Appellants have not argued any of the claims separately, all of the                    
                claims stand or fall with claim 1.                                                             


                                                   ISSUE                                                       
                      The issue is whether Appellants have shown that the Examiner erred                       
                in rejecting the claims under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a).  That is, given the                          
                teachings of the prior art, have Appellants shown that the differences                         
                between the claims and the prior art are sufficient to render the claimed                      
                subject matter unobvious to a person skilled in the art at the time the                        
                invention was made?                                                                            


                                            FINDINGS OF FACT                                                   
                      The record supports the following findings of fact (FF) by a                             
                preponderance of the evidence.                                                                 

                                                   Acharya                                                     
                 1. Acharya describes a method for providing a user-selectable version of                      
                      a file with information content in response to user selection of a                       
                      hyperlink to that information content.  (Abstract.)  Acharya teaches                     
                      that a user typically accesses files stored on the Web using a Web                       
                      browser, and that "[a] user's selection of a hyperlink acts as a user's                  
                      request for transmission of the file associated with the hyperlink to the                
                      [user's] client."  (Col. 2, ll. 9-20.)  In Acharya, the user controls which              
                      version of the file is provided.  For example, "[a] high resolution                      

                                                      7                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013