Ex Parte Braverman - Page 4

                Appeal 2007-1409                                                                              
                Application 09/823,626                                                                        

                and detecting whether an agent has enabled an event notification feature.                     
                (Br. 14, 15 and Reply Br. 3.)                                                                 
                      The Examiner asserts that the rejection is proper.  The Examiner                        
                asserts that paragraphs [0155] and [0156] of Gifford teach the limitation                     
                “determining whether the particular agent has enabled notification of                         
                account changes; and in response to detecting the event and determining that                  
                the particular agent has enabled notification of account changes, generating                  
                an electronic mail message describing the event and sending the electronic                    
                mail message to the particular agent” (Answer 10-11.)                                         
                      Thus, the issue before us is whether the combination of Tabb,                           
                Woloshin, and Gifford suggests the limitation of “determining whether the                     
                particular agent has enabled notification of account changes; and in response                 
                to detecting the event and determining that the particular agent has enabled                  
                notification of account changes, generating an e-mail” as recited in the                      
                independent claims.                                                                           

                                           FINDINGS OF FACT                                                   
                      Tabb teaches a system which uses a relational database to generate                      
                reports with hypertext links.  Abstract.  The hypertext links are used to                     
                identify relations between the data in one report and data in another report.                 
                (Col. 3, ll. 39-46.)  The system allows for the generation of shorter reports,                
                wherein a user viewing the report can select a hyperlink to access further                    
                information (drill down) contained in the linked report.  (Col. 3, ll. 53-66.)                
                One use of the system is to present sales data as related to a sales                          
                representative.  The system improves upon the prior art wherein several sales                 


                                                      4                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013