Ex Parte BEALE - Page 4



                Appeal 2007-1432                                                                             
                Application 09/141,186                                                                       
                Patent 5,549,673                                                                             

                      sizing portion corresponding respectively in size and shape to one of                  
                      the implant bodies;                                                                    
                            (c) each of the sizing portions having a sloped surface that                     
                      forms an obtuse angle with the handle axis, the sloped surface being                   
                      positioned to engage the patient’s vocal cord to be medalized;                         
                            (d) an inserter instrument that enables a surgeon to engage and                  
                      move the selected implant body in the opening in the thyroid cartilage.                

                            18. (Reissue claim) A system of phonosurgery implantation for                    
                      enabling a surgeon to insert a prosthesis through an opening formed in                 
                      a patient's thyroid cartilage to stabilize a vocal cord therein, the                   
                      system comprising:                                                                     
                            (a) a series of implant bodies of different sizes;                               
                            (b) a series of sizing instruments for enabling a surgeon to                     
                      determine the implant body to use, each having proximal and distal                     
                      end portions, the proximal end portion having a handle, the distal end                 
                      portion having a sizing portion corresponding respectively in size and                 
                      shape to one of the implant bodies; and                                                
                            (c) each of the sizing portions having a sloped surface that                     
                      forms an obtuse angle with the handle axis, the sloped surface being                   
                      positioned to engage the patient’s vocal cord to be medalized.                         

                      4. The Examiner rejected added reissue claims 16-26 under                              
                35 U.S.C. § 251 as “being an improper recapture of claimed subject matter                    
                that was deliberately canceled in the application for the patent upon which                  
                the present reissue is based”  (Supp. Answer 4-13) .                                         
                      5. The Examiner rejected reissue claims 1-3 (original patent                           
                claims 1-3) and added reissue claims 16-26 as being based on a defective                     
                reissue oath under 35 U.S.C. § 251 (Supp. Answer 13).                                        

                                                    - 4 -                                                    

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013