Ex Parte Lifson et al - Page 2



            Appeal 2007-1444                                                                               
            Application 10/732,497                                                                         

                                           THE INVENTION                                                   
                  Appellants claim a system for diagnosing a loss of refrigerant charge that               
            provides information regarding an amount of refrigerant charge within a refrigerant            
            system based upon equalized system pressure at equilibrium conditions                          
            (Specification 2:[0007]).  Claims 20 and 21, reproduced below, are the only claims             
            on appeal.                                                                                     
                         20.  A method of monitoring a refrigerant charge loss in a                        
                         refrigerant system, comprising:                                                   
                               determining an equilibrium pressure while the                               
                         system is inactive:                                                               
                               determining an ambient temperature;                                         
                               determining if a difference between an expected                             
                         pressure corresponding to the determined ambient                                  
                         temperature and the determined equilibrium pressure                               
                         exceeds a selected threshold; and                                                 
                               determining an amount of refrigerant charge loss                            
                         from the system based upon the difference between the                             
                         expected pressure and the determined equilibrium                                  
                         pressure.                                                                         

                         21. The method of claim 20, comprising determining a                              
                         percentage of refrigerant charge loss.                                            

                                           THE REJECTIONS                                                  
                  The Examiner relies upon the following as evidence of lack of novelty:                   
                   Scoccia                   US 5,481,884                   Jan. 9, 1996                   


                                                    2                                                      



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013