Ex Parte Hu et al - Page 5

                    Appeal 2007-1852                                                                                                     
                    Application 10/936,925                                                                                               

                             7) Seth teaches that the matrix material may be a MCrAlY                                                    
                                 composition or other suitable compositions provided the matrix                                          
                                 material entraps the hard particles, forms a sufficient bond                                            
                                 strength with the substrate, is resistant to high temperatures and                                      
                                 oxidation, and has sufficient mechanical properties to maintain its                                     
                                 shape on the substrate. (Seth [0010]).                                                                  
                             8) The hard particles utilized in Seth’s process include cubic                                              
                                 boron nitride, diamond or other suitable particles having an                                            
                                 appropriate level of hardness.  (Seth [0010]).  The hard particles                                      
                                 have an average nominal particle diameter of between about 0.005                                        
                                 and 0.010 inches. (Seth [0024]).                                                                        
                             9) According to Benoit, a known problem which occurs in the                                                 
                                 compressor and turbine sections of gas turbine engines is that the                                      
                                 blade tips come into proximity to the inner wall of the engine case,                                    
                                 rubbing the case wall, or an abradable seal or rubstrip located on                                      
                                 the case wall.  (Benoit, col. 1, ll. 17-20).                                                            
                             10) Benoit discloses that a known method of extending the life                                              
                                 of a blade tip is to apply abrasive layers to the blade tip surface.                                    
                                 Methods of applying the abrasive layers include powder                                                  
                                 metallurgy techniques, plasma spray techniques, and                                                     
                                 electroplating techniques.  (Benoit, col. 1, ll. 62-64).                                                
                             11) Benoit references specific prior art techniques for providing                                           
                                 an abrasive layer on a blade wherein the layer is described as                                          
                                 abrasive particulates entrapped within or encapsulated by the                                           
                                 metal matrix. (See Benoit, col. 1, l. 64 – col. 2, l. 30).                                              


                                                                   5                                                                     

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013