Ex Parte O et al - Page 3

                Appeal 2007-1878                                                                              
                Application 09/955,683                                                                        


                power management engine associated with the power supplies, such that the                     
                power management engine is operable “to adjust the power supplies to                          
                optimize power consumption.”  Although we have some strong measure of                         
                agreement with the Examiner’s basic position in the Answer that the power                     
                conservation teachings of Fung directly relate to optimizing power                            
                consumption, we do not agree with the Examiner’s urging at pages 3-5 of                       
                the Answer that the reference teaches any adjustment of the power supplies                    
                themselves as best traversed at page 2 of the Reply Brief.  Beginning at                      
                figure 2 of Fung, dual power supplies 56 are shown for each integrated                        
                server system unit in that figure.  Dual redundant power supplies are also                    
                illustrated in figure 6 showing two interconnected integrated server system                   
                units A and B.  Figure 9 shows two server modules 402, each of which                          
                contains a CPU voltage generator control unit 416 whereas figure 10 shows                     
                a comparable voltage regulator 324 for each ISSU server module 302.  A                        
                corresponding voltage regulator is shown at the bottom right of the figure                    
                apparently as an unlabeled element, but characterized in the discussion                       
                bridging column 26 and 27 as voltage regulators 241.                                          




                                                      3                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013