Ex Parte Foley - Page 4

                Appeal  2007-2372                                                                                
                Application 10/395,654                                                                           
                       3. Morris discloses an implant retaining device for securing “an                          
                intervertebral implant in a receiving bed formed between adjacent vertebrae”                     
                (Morris, p. 1, par. 3).                                                                          
                       4. The method of Claim 29 requires “an implant formed of bone” (Br.                       
                App. A).                                                                                         
                       5. Michelson teaches that its implant is “any interbody spinal fusion                     
                implant regardless of the material from which it is formed, including …                          
                cortical bone, and other material useful for the intended purpose”                               
                (Michelson, p. 2, par. 41).                                                                      
                       6. Claim 29 recites an implant having “a body portion with an upper                       
                bearing surface and opposite lower bearing surface” (Br. App. A).                                
                       7. Michelson’s implant “has a vertebral body engaging upper surface                       
                110 and an opposite vertebral body engaging lower surface 112”                                   
                (Michelson, p. 2-3, par. 42).                                                                    
                       8. Claim 29 recites “a flexible upper flange member and an opposite                       
                flexible lower flange member” (Br. App. A).                                                      
                       9. Michelson employs an interbody implant with the trailing end                           
                configured into a flanged portion (Michelson, p. 3, par. 44).                                    
                       10.  Morris describes an implant retaining plate.  “When the plate is                     
                formed from bone, it may be partially or fully demineralized.  Partially                         

                                                       4                                                         

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013