Ex Parte Das - Page 6

                Appeal 2007-2557                                                                             
                Application 10/094,866                                                                       
                                          FINDINGS OF FACT4                                                  
                Claim Interpretation                                                                         
                      1.  The phrase “the strand of material being configured to include a                   
                repeating series of interconnected repeating W-shaped strand configurations                  
                having a repeating dip, rise, dip, rise, loop, dip, rise, dip, rise, loop patterned          
                configuration” does not, to our knowledge, have a well-recognized meaning                    
                in the stent art.  Further it is not defined in the Specification, except through            
                the description of a preferred embodiment.  Significantly, it is not limited by              
                the claim language to a configuration shown in any of the figures, for                       
                example with language such as “shown in Fig. 9.”  Thus, we give these                        
                claim terms their broadest reasonable interpretation consistent with the                     
                Specification.                                                                               
                      2.  The term “loop” means:  “a curving or doubling of a line so as to                  
                form a closed or partially open curve within itself through which another                    
                line can be passed or a hook may be hooked.”  Webster’s Ninth New                            
                Collegiate Dictionary 705 (1990) (“Webster’s”).                                              
                      3.  The language “include” prefaces “a repeating series of                             
                interconnected repeating W-shaped strand configurations having a repeating                   
                dip, rise, dip, rise, loop, dip, rise, dip, rise, loop patterned configuration.”             
                Thus, the claim language does not exclude additional twists and turns, et                    
                cetera, from the configuration, so long as the configuration satisfies the                   
                language of the claim.                                                                       
                      4.  The terms in the claim phrase “a plurality of narrowings . . . in the              
                interconnection bridge that permit the interconnection bridge to have greater                
                flexibility when bending” are not further defined in the Specification.                      
                                                                                                            
                4 Findings of Fact are abbreviated “FF.”                                                     

                                                     6                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013