Ex Parte Suzuki - Page 5

               Appeal 2007-2921                                                                             
               Application 09/951,452                                                                       
               as multilayered bitstreams where the most significant bit (MSB) represents                   
               the base layer while the least significant bits (LSBs) represent the                         
               enhancement layers.  (Col. 8, l. 65- col. 9, l. 11.)                                         
                      6. Park discloses a bit packing portion (240) for sequentially                        
               encoding the quantized values from MSBs to LSBs.  Particularly, the bit                      
               packing portion codes the side information corresponding to the base layer                   
               and the enhancement layers resulting from the quantization.  (Col. 6, ll. 1-                 
               20.)                                                                                         
                      7. As depicted in Figure 14, Park discloses that, in the prior art, an                
               original signal is sampled and filtered to produce digital signal bands that are             
               encoded.  The encoded signals are fed to a bitstream multiplexer.  They are                  
               also decoded, inverse filtered and up-sampled to re-construct the original                   
               signal.  The reconstructed signal is compared to the original signal in an                   
               adder to generate an error.  The error is subsequently encoded before it is                  
               recombined with the encoded signal data in the bitstream multiplexer.  (Col.                 
               2, ll. 60-67.)                                                                               







                                                                                                           
               becomes smaller than the masking threshold.”  (Col. 5, ll. 54-56.) (Emphasis                 
               added.)                                                                                      
               4 The Examiner notes in passing that the teachings of the prior art alone, in                
               Figure 1 of Park, anticipate the invention, as claimed.  (Answer 6.)  We                     
               agree.                                                                                       
                                                     5                                                      

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013