Ex Parte Price - Page 8

                Appeal 2007-4310                                                                             
                Application 10/950,830                                                                       
                9.    Price describes a method of making the claimed composite sheets or                     
                liners in the following words:                                                               
                      a portion of the liquid foamable material is removed, after it is                      
                      applied, from what will be the decorative surface 18, for                              
                      example with a knife or other blade. . . . The scraping leaves at                      
                      least some portions of the fibers on the decorative surface 18                         
                      which, at least to the naked eye, are completely free of the                           
                      foamed material.                                                                       
                (830 Application at 5, ¶ 24.)                                                                
                10. As a result, according to Price, "[t]he coating on the non-slip                          
                surface 16 is thus generally thicker, on average, than on the decorative                     
                surface.  This results in a larger portion of the foam being on the side of the              
                scrim adjacent surface 16 after foaming and drying."  (830 Application at 5,                 
                ¶ 24.)                                                                                       
                      Mangum                                                                                 
                11. Mangum relates to non-slip products such as kitchen drawer inserts                       
                having multiple scrims, each coated with liquid polyvinyl chloride that is                   
                then baked in an oven to form foamed coating layers around the scrims.                       
                (Mangum at 1:7-17.)                                                                          
                12. Mangum describes the coated scrims as being "welded" together when                       
                they are heated together in the oven.  (Mangum, e.g., at 2:65 and at 3:62.)                  
                13. Mangum teaches that a variety of scrims may be used (Mangum                              
                at 1:37–61), stating that "the type of scrim utilized often effects [sic: affects]           
                the porosity, as well as amount of coating retained by the scrim."  (Mangum                  
                at 1:61–63.)                                                                                 



                                                    8                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013