The Brinson Company-Midwest, Inc., et al - Page 14

                                       - 14 -                                         
          concern that the payments to Brigitte were for a purpose other              
          than to prevent competition.  See id.; Ackerman v. Commissioner,            
          T.C. Memo. 1968-254.                                                        
               Petitioners contend that respondent's reallocation between             
          the stock redemption and the covenant not to compete is                     
          erroneous.  Petitioners focus their argument on respondent's                
          assumption and conclusion regarding the health and abilities of             
          Brigitte.  Petitioners do not dispute that Brigitte died from               
          cirrhosis of the liver; however, petitioners explain that                   
          Brigitte's health complications occurred and became known to the            
          parties after the agreements were executed.                                 
               Petitioners had ample opportunity to dispel respondent's               
          erroneous assumption, yet they failed to do so.  On at least two            
          occasions, respondent's agent sought access to Brigitte's medical           
          records only to be denied the opportunity by petitioners.                   
               Petitioners also argue that they computed the value                    
          allocated to the covenant several times and that their valuation,           
          and not respondent's valuation, is correct.  This may very well             
          be true, but petitioners failed to produce their computations or            
          deliver them to respondent when requested.  In fact, the record             
          indicates that petitioners were uncooperative with respondent up            
          until early 1995, shortly before these cases were scheduled for             
          trial.                                                                      
               Having reviewed these cases based upon the available                   
          information, we find respondent's position credible.  Petitioners           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011