Estate of Willis Edward Clack, Deceased, Marshall & Ilsley Trust Company, Co-Personal Representative, and Richard E. Clack, Co-Personal Representative - Page 22

                                       - 22 -                                         
               death except the requirement of election.  This would                  
               effectively reduce the election requirement to a mere                  
               formality, defeat its apparent purpose and its most                    
               reasonable interpretation. * * *                                       
                         *    *    *    *    *    *    *                              
                    This decision is in keeping with the overarching                  
               purpose of Congress to liberalize the requirements                     
               surrounding the marital deduction.  The 1981 amendments                
               to section 2056 made a number of changes, each of which                
               expanded the scope of the marital deduction.  In this                  
               spirit, we think an interpretation favoring the                        
               allowance of the deduction is in keeping with                          
               Congressional intent.  It recognizes that wills are                    
               often drafted long in advance of death and that family                 
               situations and the value of assets may change                          
               dramatically.  There is no reason to interpret section                 
               2056(b)(7) to require that the will identify QTIP                      
               property long in advance of death and thereby deny                     
               taxpayers the full advantage of the marital deduction                  
               for QTIP property.  The election provision is plain                    
               enough and seems purposely worded to avoid this estate                 
               planning problem.  [43 F.3d at 230-233.]                               

               In the QTIP definitional requirements of section                       
          2056(b)(7)(B), because it is the first date on which the claimed            
          QTIP property could possibly qualify under section 2056(b)(7)(B),           
          the date on which the estate tax return is filed is the only                
          directly relevant date.  If, on that date, all of the                       
          requirements have been satisfied (namely, the property passed               
          from the decedent, the surviving spouse then has a qualifying               
          income interest for life, and the election has been made on the             
          return), the property should “be treated”, see sec.                         
          2056(b)(7)(A)(i), as fully meeting the definitional requirements            
          of section 2056(b)(7)(B).                                                   






Page:  Previous  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011