Richard H. Daley and Estate of Anne H. Daley, Deceased, Richard H. Daley, Executor - Page 11

                                       - 11 -                                         
          that someone claiming a particular activity is motivated by                 
          profit would not know simple but significant information such as            
          this with respect to that activity.                                         
               Respondent also points to numerous omissions in petitioner's           
          records as further support for her contention that petitioner               
          lacked the requisite profit motive with respect to his horse                
          activity.  We agree.  While maintaining less than precise records           
          does not conclusively establish the lack of a profit objective,             
          see Engdahl v. Commissioner, 72 T.C. 659, 666-667 (1979),                   
          petitioner's records are so fraught with omissions and                      
          inconsistencies that it is difficult to imagine how they served             
          any beneficial purpose.  Petitioner's records do not reflect the            
          income and expenses associated with each individual horse, and              
          petitioner testified that he could not otherwise tell from his              
          records whether any one horse was profitable in any particular              
          year.  Similarly, as noted earlier, petitioner's records do not             
          reflect the activity's past losses.  Furthermore, petitioner                
          testified that the ledger contained various data pertaining to              
          each horse; however, respondent has shown that much of such data            
          is lacking from the ledger.  Petitioner's drop files are equally            
          incomplete.  In fact, petitioner failed to maintain a drop file             
          on several of his horses.  The drop files are supposed to contain           
          information pertaining to registration and breeding, among other            
          things, but such information is lacking from several of the files           
          that do exist.  Not only are petitioner's records incomplete,               




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011