Estate of Catherine E. Dowell, Deceased, Patricia Low, Executrix - Page 24

                                       - 24 -                                         
          to court to enforce the equitable lien on the stock.  The record            
          is replete with compelling evidence that decedent conducted                 
          business only on her own terms.  Simply put, business                       
          arrangements were done her way or not at all.  Decedent would not           
          have wanted her daughter to keep the stock if she did not follow            
          her wishes.                                                                 
               Having eliminated the creation of a charge or an option to             
          purchase, we are left with a condition, precedent or subsequent,            
          as best reflecting the probable intent of decedent.  This                   
          interpretation is consistent with petitioner's argument and                 
          respondent's alternative argument on brief that decedent wanted             
          the bequest of stock to be subject to a condition.                          
               We believe the best indication of decedent's intent can be             
          derived from how she handled an earlier transaction with her                
          daughter, her sale of 25 percent of the agency stock to her                 
          daughter.  The agreement, like the will, called for 10 years of             
          monthly payments.  The stock was issued in Patricia Low's name as           
          of the effective date of the agreement, January 1, 1990.                    
          Although Patricia Low became the owner of 25 percent of the                 
          agency stock on January 1, 1990, physical possession of the stock           
          certificate was to be withheld, by her mother's instruction,                
          until all the payments had been made.  When a single payment was            
          made late, decedent threatened to tear up her daughter's stock              
          certificate.                                                                






Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011