Estate of James F. Hall, Jr., Deceased, Harriet Hall, Executrix, and Harriet Nixon Hall - Page 15

                                       - 15 -                                         
          circumstances giving rise to the substantial understatement and,            
          thus, does not qualify as an innocent spouse under section                  
          6013(e)(1)(C).                                                              
               Moreover, we find that Mrs. Hall failed to meet the inequity           
          requirements of section 6013(e)(1)(D).  Whether it is inequitable           
          to hold a spouse liable is to be determined on the basis of all             
          the facts and circumstances.  Sec. 6013(e)(1)(D); sec. 1.6013-              
          5(b), Income Tax Regs.  Although section 6013(e), as amended, no            
          longer specifically requires us to determine whether a spouse               
          significantly benefited from the omitted income, this factor is             
          still to be taken into account in determining whether it is                 
          inequitable to hold a spouse liable.  Estate of Krock v.                    
          Commissioner, 93 T.C. 672, 678 (1989).  Mrs. Hall bears the                 
          burden of proving that she did not significantly benefit from the           
          omitted income.  Id.                                                        
               Mrs. Hall argues that it would be inequitable to hold her              
          liable, because she did not receive any benefit from the                    
          distribution in the form of better day-to-day living conditions.            
          Mrs. Hall's day-to-day living conditions do not appear to have              
          improved as a result of the distribution.  However, of the cash             
          distributed from the Plan in 1988, $474,768.81 was transferred to           
          an account held jointly by Mr. and Mrs. Hall.  Both Mr. and Mrs.            
          Hall executed the deposit agreement for the account.  In                    
          addition, a certificate of deposit held by the Plan was redeemed            
          and the proceeds were used to purchase a money market certificate           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011