Hospital Corporation of America and Subsidiaries - Page 41

                                       - 41 -                                         
               * of $777,041,795; and (iv) through the assumption by                  
               the Subsidiaries of all of the obligations of Parent                   
               [HCA] * * * of $7,763,924.                                             
                                                                                     
               Respondent's position that the parties agreed to a fair                
          market value of $460 million for the Securities rests on a number           
          of assumptions.  The first assumption is that the Bankers Trust             
          model determined that the fair market value of the Facilities was           
          $2,099,970,000.  The second assumption is that the aggregate                
          value of the stock of the Subsidiaries equaled the fair market              
          value of the Facilities--HealthTrust purchased the stock of the             
          Subsidiaries, not the assets they owned.  The third assumption is           
          that the parties agreed that the value of the Securities equaled            
          the difference between the sum of the cash HCAII received plus              
          the debt HealthTrust assumed and $2,099,970,000.                            
               The record, however, reveals that there was no agreement               
          among the parties as to the fair market value of the Securities,            
          of the stock of the Subsidiaries, or of the Facilities.  To the             
          contrary, the record supports petitioners' contention that the              
          $2,099,970,000 purchase price as originally formulated was                  
          "backed into" so that HealthTrust's balance sheet would reflect             
          equity equal to 15 percent of the cash that petitioners expected            
          to derive from the transaction.  No HealthTrust Management                  
          representative participated in negotiations with the lenders or             
          with HCA Management representatives in determining the terms of             
          the Acquisition.  At trial, petitioners presented evidence,                 
          uncontroverted by respondent, that no HCA Management                        




Page:  Previous  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011