M.S. Food Stores, Inc. - Page 26

                                       - 26 -                                         
          deposits.  On the whole, that has not been established.                     
               The totals of the personal checks Mr. Sutton wrote to or on            
          behalf of the corporate petitioner are summarized in the Findings           
          of Fact above.  However, most of the personal checks that were              
          deposited were part of the store deposits and, thus, do not                 
          reduce the corporate petitioner's unexplained bank deposits.                
          Those checks that were deposited separately from the store                  
          deposits and that do not constitute income to the corporate                 
          petitioner are listed separately in the Findings of Fact above.             
               As for the proceeds of personal checks that were cashed, Mr.           
          Sutton could not remember their specific disposition and, thus,             
          could not correlate their proceeds to the unexplained bank                  
          deposits.  Checks written to third parties do not explain bank              
          deposits.  There is no credible evidence of any cash                        
          contributions from Mr. Sutton to the corporate petitioner, either           
          from any of his personal funds or from any funds deriving from              
          Mr. Palmer.                                                                 
               Both the corporate petitioner and the individual petitioners           
          allege that Mr. Sutton loaned small amounts to the corporate                
          petitioner regularly and withdrew small amounts regularly, in               
          essence, alleging that the same funds were loaned and repaid over           
          and over.  They argue that respondent has distorted the corporate           
          petitioner's income by summing the amounts advanced without                 
          subtracting the repayments.  Petitioners point to Ms. Stroud's              






Page:  Previous  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011