Lawrence J. Polidori - Page 18

                                       - 18 -                                         
               With respect to taxable year 1985, respondent has not                  
          carried her burden in establishing the existence of an                      
          underpayment.  Respondent cannot rely on petitioner's failure to            
          establish a nontaxable source for the bank deposits discussed               
          earlier in this opinion in order to satisfy her burden.  Otsuki             
          v. Commissioner, supra.  Instead, if the bank deposits are to be            
          considered in determining whether an underpayment exists,                   
          respondent must establish by clear and convincing evidence that             
          such deposits were unreported income.  She has not done so.                 
          Hence, in determining whether an underpayment exists, the bank              
          deposits may not be considered.  Therefore, because the amount of           
          the additional charitable deduction conceded by respondent for              
          taxable year 1985 exceeds the unreported interest income conceded           
          by petitioner for that year, we find that respondent has not                
          established by clear and convincing evidence that an underpayment           
          exists for taxable year 1985.                                               
               Respondent has also failed to establish the existence of an            
          underpayment for taxable year 1986.  As is the case for taxable             
          year 1985, and for the same reasons, the bank deposits cannot be            
          considered when determining whether an underpayment exists for              
          taxable year 1986.  Accordingly, because the amount of the                  
          additional charitable deduction conceded by respondent for                  
          taxable year 1986 exceeds the unreported interest income conceded           
          by petitioner for that year, we find that respondent has not                






Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011