Bruce and Lois Zenkel, et al. - Page 34

                                       - 34 -                                         
          know how many recyclers SAB Reclamation leased or who                       
          manufactured the recyclers.  Blount had no idea who the general             
          partner of Phoenix was, how a Sentinel EPE recycler worked, the             
          value placed on the recyclers, how many recyclers Phoenix leased,           
          or how he was going to make a profit from his investment.  David            
          did not know how many recyclers SAB Recycling purchased or the              
          price of each machine.  Selvin knew nothing about resin prices,             
          was not aware of any companies that would be suitable end-users,            
          and did not know whether Scarborough had any assets, or how the             
          venture was to work.                                                        
               Petitioners failed to explain how the so-called oil crisis,            
          or the media coverage of it, provided a reasonable basis for them           
          to invest in the Partnerships and claim the associated tax                  
          deductions and credits.  The offering materials warned that there           
          could be no assurances that prices for new resin pellets would              
          remain at their then current level.  One of respondent's experts,           
          Steven Grossman, explained that the price of plastics materials             
          is not directly proportional to the price of oil.  In his report,           
          he stated that less than 10 percent of crude oil is utilized for            
          making plastics materials, and that studies have shown that "a              
          300% increase in crude oil prices results in only a 30 to 40%               
          increase in the cost of plastics products."  Moreover, during               
          1980 and 1981, in addition to the media coverage of the so-called           
          oil crisis, there was "extensive continuing press coverage of               






Page:  Previous  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011