Frederic S. Clayton and Marlene B. Clayton - Page 17

                                                - 17 -                                                   
            between the definition of "return" as found in sections 6103(b)                              
            of the Code and 9781.348.2 of the manual and "return" as used in                             
            section 6211 or defined in section 6213(g)(1), we also do not see                            
            how those definitions help petitioners.  Consequently, we                                    
            conclude that the cover letter and the conversations between                                 
            their accountant and respondent's employees do not constitute a                              
            return.                                                                                      
                  Respondent issued a refund to petitioners for the amount                               
            requested on the third amended return.  Accordingly, we hold that                            
            there was no erroneous action by respondent and that the refund                              
            was based on a recalculation of petitioners' tax liability and                               
            that the refund of $65,937 does come within the statutory                                    
            framework of section 6211 for purposes of calculating                                        
            petitioners' 1985 tax deficiency.  We have considered all of the                             
            other arguments made by petitioners and, to the extent we have                               
            not addressed them, find them to be without merit.                                           
                  To reflect the foregoing,                                                              
                                                             Decision will be entered                    
                                                       under Rule 155.                                   














Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  

Last modified: May 25, 2011