Edward S. Cullin - Page 4

                                                 - 4 -                                                   
                required to be registered as a commodity trading adviser                                 
                (CTA).  Petitioner applied for and, in 1986, obtained                                    
                registration as a CTA with the Commodity Futures Trading                                 
                Commission (CFTC).  He also applied for and, in 1987,                                    
                obtained registration as a CTA with the National Futures                                 
                Association (NFA).                                                                       
                      The NFA is an association responsible for regulating                               
                the professional conduct and financial responsibility of                                 
                CTA's and others, including futures commissions merchants,                               
                introducing brokers, and commodity pool operators.  As part                              
                of its regulatory activities the NFA conducts periodic                                   
                audits of its members and monitors their advertising and                                 
                sales practices.                                                                         
                      Petitioner encountered two problems in 1988 with                                   
                respect to his manuscript.  First, on October 3, 1988, the                               
                WSJ changed the format of its Commodities Page by expanding                              
                it to two pages with two lead stories.  Petitioner believed                              
                the new format would cause problems for his customers                                    
                because his manuscript was premised upon evaluating only                                 
                one lead article per day.  Petitioner believed that readers                              
                of the manuscript would become confused as to which, if                                  
                any, commodity they should trade on a particular day.                                    
                      Second, on December 14, 1987, the NFA began a periodic                             
                audit of petitioner, and on May 13, 1988, it issued an                                   
                audit report to petitioner.  The audit report discussed                                  




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011