John M. and Rita K. Monahan - Page 33

                                       - 33 -                                         
          the funds held by Aldergrove, in conjunction with petitioners'              
          concession that Aldergrove was the source of the funds allegedly            
          loaned to petitioner by Hansa Finance, $200,000 ($23,382 +                  
          $176,618) on March 1, 1987, and $110,000 on March 1, 1988, cast             
          doubt on petitioners' version of the loan transactions.                     
               A reasonable inference to be drawn from the sua sponte                 
          issues is that petitioner's relationship with Aldergrove did not            
          change between February 26, 1987, and December 22, 1988, which              
          would mean that petitioner controlled Aldergrove partnership                
          matters and benefited from and controlled the funds held by                 
          Aldergrove when Aldergrove likely transferred to Hansa Finance              
          the funds that were loaned back to petitioner.  Therefore,                  
          petitioners would have us believe that petitioner (1) in                    
          substance, transferred funds to Hansa Finance, (2) borrowed those           
          funds back from Hansa Finance, (3) made loans with those funds to           
          Chestnut Grove and Group M, (4) removed himself from the loan               
          transactions by means of certain agreements, (5) received                   
          interest payments from Chestnut Grove and Group M by means of his           
          relationship with Aldergrove on December 26, 1991, but (6) held             
          the interest in trust for Mr. Bell because Mr. Bell was the                 
          ultimate source of the funds loaned to Chestnut Grove and                   
          Group M.                                                                    









Page:  Previous  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011