Nathan P. and Geraldine V. Morton - Page 33

                                       - 33 -                                         
             new SWI stock after the transaction.  It was just one                    
             component of the overall acquisition transaction in which                
             Dubin Clark acquired the interests of Messrs. Jacobson                   
             and Henochowicz in old SWI, and was not a separate arm's-                
             length sale reflecting the fair market value of the                      
             specific block of stock.  Accordingly, the price                         
             established in the acquisition transaction does not                      
             necessarily reflect the fair market value of the stock at                
             that time, or 6 months later when petitioner acquired the                
             stock at issue.                                                          
                  Moreover, Dubin Clark established the Share                         
             Compensation Plan for the express purpose of attracting                  
             talented management to SWI.  One way to accomplish this                  
             purpose was to offer prospective managers a significant                  
             discount on the shares made available for purchase.  The                 
             language of the stock plan itself confirms that the board                
             of directors contemplated selling stock at less than fair                
             market value.  Paragraph 4(a) of the stock plan provides                 
             as follows:                                                              

                  The purchase price for the shares of Common                         
                  Stock to be offered and sold from time to time                      
                  by the Company pursuant to this Plan shall be                       
                  initially $60.98 per share and thereafter as                        
                  determined from time to time by the Board.  The                     
                  Board is authorized to offer and sell shares of                     
                  Common Stock pursuant to this plan at less than                     
                  fair market value in order to compensate                            
                  qualified employees, directors, officers,                           
                  consultants and advisers of the Company * * *                       




Page:  Previous  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  39  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011