Steven J. and Jean L. Liddane - Page 12

                                       - 12 -                                         

               the same confidence.  But where it is a recent dictum                  
               that considers all the relevant considerations and                     
               adumbrates an unmistakable conclusion, it would be                     
               reckless to think the Court likely to adopt a contrary                 
               view in the near future.  In such a case the dictum                    
               provides the best, though not an infallible guide to                   
               what the law is, and it will ordinarily be the duty of                 
               a lower court to be guided by it.                                      
          So much more so in the case at hand, as in the countless other              
          cases in which misguided taxpayers such as petitioners have                 
          repeated the fruitless arguments that the income tax laws are               
          ineffective or inapplicable in accomplishing their intended                 
          objective of raising governmental revenue from individuals                  
          who receive wage, salary, or other compensation income.  The                
          invariable practice of this Court and the Courts of Appeals in              
          rejecting those arguments confirms that petitioners' arguments              
          are frivolous.  By enacting and amending the Internal Revenue               
          Code, Congress, the people's elected representatives, has                   
          accomplished the purpose of providing the primary means of                  
          financing the costs of the Federal Government.  This is the                 
          system under which both individuals and corporations will be                
          required to pay their shares of the burden, at least until such             
          time as Congress decides to repeal the income tax and try another           
          way to raise the necessary revenue.                                         
               Petitioners' descriptions of the Federal income tax as a               
          voluntary system that they and others who don't like to pay taxes           
          can elect to participate in or not as they choose are based on a            
          gross misunderstanding that can only be attributed to willful               




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011