Prindle International Marketing, UBO, Keyus Group, Trustee - Page 18

                                        -18-                                          
               Petitioners contend that the Oxyfresh payments to Prindle or           
          to Mr. Fox are passive income because they were a percentage of             
          all Oxyfresh company sales, not only sales from distributors that           
          he recruited.  We disagree.  The payments from Oxyfresh were not            
          passive income because Mr. Fox's activities to earn them were not           
          passive.  Mr. Fox had to work for Oxyfresh to receive payments              
          from Oxyfresh.  Mr. Fox owned Oxyfresh stock, but petitioners do            
          not contend that the payments from Oxyfresh were dividends.                 
               Petitioners contend that the Oxyfresh payments are not self-           
          employment income because they would continue even after Mr. Fox            
          died.  For reasons stated in paragraph B-2, we are not convinced            
          that Oxyfresh would continue to make payments after Mr. Fox died.           
               Petitioners rely on Gump v. United States, 86 F.3d 1126,               
          1128 (Fed. Cir. 1996), in which the U.S. Court of Appeals for the           
          Federal Circuit held that payments from Nationwide Mutual                   
          Insurance Co.'s Agency Security Compensation Plan to a retired              
          independent agent who sold Nationwide policies were not subject             
          to self-employment tax.  In Gump, the Government contended that             
          the payments were part of the taxpayer's compensation for selling           
          insurance.  Id.  The Court of Appeals disagreed and held that               
          payments were made to cancel the payor's business relationship              
          with the taxpayer.  Id.  The Court of Appeals held that the                 
          payments to cancel the business relationship were not self-                 
          employment income.  Id.  Oxyfresh did not pay Mr. Fox or Prindle            






Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011