James Triplett - Page 10

                                       - 10 -                                         

          Order.  At that time in 1998, respondent determined the 1981                
          return tendered by petitioner to the revenue officer in 1985                
          constituted a valid tax return and conceded this case solely on             
          the grounds that the period of limitations had run.  Although               
          respondent ultimately conceded this matter, we find the revenue             
          agent had a reasonable basis in fact and in law to question the             
          return tendered in 1985.  Based on these facts, the position of             
          the United States before this Court was substantially justified.            
               Further, we also conclude that petitioner unreasonably                 
          protracted the Court proceedings.  Sec. 7430(b)(3).  Petitioner             
          delayed resolution of this case in this Court proceeding because            
          he did not provide the copy of the 1981 return to respondent                
          until the eve of trial.  Among other things, petitioner's action            
          caused respondent to submit a motion under Rule 91(f), a trial              
          memorandum, and three motions to quash subpoenas.  The Court held           
          a conference call with the parties and by a March 20, 1998, Order           
          set respondent's motions to quash subpoenas for hearing on March            
          23, 1998.  All these acts could have been avoided if petitioner             
          had provided respondent the copy of petitioner's 1981 income tax            
          return in response to respondent's June 4, 1997, letter.                    
               For all the foregoing reasons, petitioner's motion for                 
          litigation and administrative costs is denied.                              
                                                  An appropriate order and            
                                             decision will be entered.                





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  

Last modified: May 25, 2011